CELPIP SPEAKING · TASK 5
CELPIP Speaking Task 5: compare two options and persuade convincingly
Task 5 is the only Speaking task with two stages. First you choose between two options. Then a family member suggests a different option, and you must persuade them that your choice is better. The key is comparison: explain why yours is better than theirs, not only why yours is good.
By CELPIP Studio · Updated
How CELPIP Speaking Task 5 works
| Task type | Comparing and Persuading |
|---|---|
| Preparation time | 60 seconds |
| Speaking time | 60 seconds |
| Rated on | Content/Coherence, Vocabulary, Listenability, Task Fulfillment |
In the first stage you have 60 seconds to choose one of two options with details such as price and location. In the second stage, a third option appears. You have 60 seconds to prepare and 60 seconds to persuade the other person to accept your choice. Check the official CELPIP test format before test day in case details change.
A flexible Task 5 template
Use this as a plan for your preparation time, not as sentences to memorize. Raters reward responses that fit the specific prompt.
| Step | Timing | What to do | Useful phrases |
|---|---|---|---|
| State your choice | 0–8 s | Name the person and your recommendation immediately. | “I know you like the…, but I really think the… is the better choice.” |
| Comparison point 1 | 8–28 s | Compare one feature directly, using the details given. | “Although yours is cheaper, mine…” “…is much closer than…” “Compared with…, this one…” |
| Comparison point 2 | 28–48 s | Compare a second feature, ideally one that matters to the listener. | “On top of that, …” “More importantly for you, …” |
| Answer their concern and close | 48–60 s | Acknowledge one advantage of their option and explain why it matters less. | “I understand that…, but…” “So overall, I think … makes more sense.” |
CELPIP Speaking Task 5 sample answer
Sample 1: A focused comparative response
Prompt: You chose a weekend cabin by a lake (CA$180 a night, 2 hours’ drive, kayaks included) for a family trip. Your brother prefers a downtown hotel (CA$140 a night, 30 minutes away, near restaurants and shopping). Persuade him.
Hey Marco, I know the downtown hotel looks cheaper, but I really think the lake cabin is the better choice for this trip.
First of all, the whole point of this weekend is to relax together. Downtown, we’d probably end up shopping and eating out, which is what we do every weekend anyway. At the cabin, we can actually spend time as a family.
Also, although the hotel is forty dollars less per night, the cabin includes kayaks. Renting kayaks in the city would easily cost more than forty dollars for all of us, so in the end the cabin is better value.
I understand the drive is longer, but two hours isn’t bad, and I’m happy to do the driving. So I really think the cabin will make this trip special.
Why it works:
- Every point compares the two options instead of describing only one.
- Uses the numbers from the prompt to build an argument (forty dollars versus kayak rental).
- Addresses the brother’s likely objection (the long drive) and offers a solution.
Original CELPIP Studio sample for study. It is not an official CELPIP question or an examiner-rated response, and it is not a script to memorize.
Read the sample aloud with a 60 seconds timer to feel the pace. Then answer a different prompt in your own words.
Common Task 5 mistakes
- Describing only your option. This is a persuasion task. Compare features directly: cheaper, closer, more useful for this person.
- Ignoring the details given. Use prices, distances and features from the screen. They are the evidence for your argument.
- Changing your choice. Do not agree with the other person. Persuade them to accept your original choice.
- Being rude. Persuasion should be friendly. Acknowledge their reason before explaining why yours is better.
Practice topics for Task 5
Prepare a 30-second plan for each topic, then record a full answer with a timer:
- Two apartments to rent
- Two summer camps for a child
- Two used cars
- Two venues for a party
- Two gym memberships
- Two vacation packages
CELPIP Speaking Task 5: common questions
How does CELPIP Speaking Task 5 work?
There are two stages. First you have 60 seconds to choose one of two options. Then a family member suggests a third option. You get 60 seconds to prepare and 60 seconds to persuade them that your option is better.
Should I agree with the other person in CELPIP Speaking Task 5?
No. The task asks you to persuade them to choose your option. You can acknowledge a strength of their choice, but your conclusion should support your own.
What comparison phrases are useful for CELPIP Speaking Task 5?
Use comparatives and contrast words: “much closer than”, “better value”, “although yours is cheaper”, “compared with”, “on the other hand” and “more importantly”. Link each one to a specific detail from the options.